The Ultimate Ice Cube Tray Buying Guide

Ice cubes may seem like a simple part of our daily lives, but choosing the right tray can make a big difference in your drinks and overall cooling experience. Whether hosting a party, enjoying a refreshing beverage, or using ice for culinary purposes, a suitable ice cube tray can elevate your ice-making game. In this ultimate ice cube tray buying guide, we’ll explore everything you need to know to make an informed purchase and keep cool.

Material Matters

The first decision you’ll need to make when buying an ice cube tray is the material it’s made from. There are three common materials to choose from:


Plastic ice cube trays are affordable and lightweight. They are available in various shapes and sizes, making them versatile. However, they may not be as durable as other materials, and some may retain odours from the freezer.


Silicone ice cube trays are flexible, making releasing ice cubes easy. They are also non-stick and dishwasher safe. Silicone trays are available in various shapes and sizes and are known for their durability.


Metal ice cube trays, often made from stainless steel, are the most durable option. They are less likely to crack or break and can last long. However, they can be more expensive and heavier than plastic or silicone trays.

Ice Cube Tray Shapes

Ice cube trays come in various shapes and sizes, each designed for specific purposes and occasions. Choosing the right form can enhance your drink presentation and influence your beverage’s taste. Here are some popular ice cube tray shapes and their ideal uses:

Standard Cubes

These are the classic, square-shaped ice cubes. They are versatile and suitable for beverages, from water and soda to cocktails and iced coffee. Classic cubes melt quickly, whether good or bad, depending on the drink.

Large Cubes

Larger ice cubes, often called “king cubes” or “whiskey cubes,” are perfect for drinks where you want to avoid dilution. These cubes melt more slowly, making them ideal for whiskey, bourbon, or other premium spirits. They also work well in cocktails, keeping your drink colder for longer without watering it down too quickly.


Ice cube trays that produce spherical ice cubes are famous for cocktails and whiskey. These ice spheres have a smaller surface area than cubes, which means they melt more slowly and are less likely to dilute your drink. The spherical shape is also visually pleasing and gives an air of sophistication to your drink.

Crushed Ice 

Some ice cube trays are designed to produce small, crushed ice cubes or crushed-style ice. These are commonly used in tiki-style cocktails, snow cones, and blended beverages like slushies and margaritas.


Diamond-shaped ice cubes are a stylish choice for upscale cocktails and events. They add a touch of sophistication to your drinks and are a conversation starter at parties.


Nugget-shaped ice cubes resemble small, irregularly shaped nuggets. They are often used in commercial ice machines and are known for their chewable texture. Nugget ice is perfect for soft drinks, iced tea, and cocktails, as it cools quickly and is easy to chew.

Heart Shapes 

Heart-shaped ice cubes are a romantic and fun choice for special occasions like Valentine’s Day or anniversary celebrations. They add a whimsical touch to your drinks and can be a delightful surprise for your loved ones.

Novelty Shapes 

Novelty ice cube trays come in various fun shapes, from animals and fruit to famous landmarks. These trays are perfect for themed parties or events, allowing you to create unique and memorable ice cubes that match the occasion.

Easy Release and Stackability

Choosing an ice cube tray that’s easy to release ice cubes from is essential. Look for trays with flexible silicone or non-stick surfaces that make it simple to pop out cubes without struggling or breaking them. Additionally, consider stackable trays, which maximise freezer space and help keep your ice cubes fresh.

Lid or No Lid

Some ice cube trays come with lids, which help prevent spills, odours, or freezer burns. Lidded trays are handy if you want to stack them or if your freezer tends to produce strong odours.

BPA-Free and Food-Grade

When it comes to culinary tools, safety is of the utmost importance. Ensure that the ice cube tray you choose is BPA-free and made from food-grade materials to guarantee your ice is safe to consume.

Ease of Cleaning

Cleaning ice cube trays can be a hassle, so choose trays that are dishwasher safe for quick and easy cleanup.

Quantity Matters

Consider how many ice cubes you’ll need at once. If you regularly host parties or have a large family, opting for trays with higher cube counts may be more convenient.

How Can I Prevent Ice Cubes From Sticking To The Tray?

Ice cubes might stick to the ice cube tray, but there are ways to remove them. Here are some tips:

Use Silicone Ice Cube Trays 

Silicone ice cube trays are naturally non-stick and are generally easier to work with than plastic or metal trays. Consider switching to silicone trays if you have trouble sticking ice cubes.

Rinse the Tray with Warm Water 

Before filling the tray with water, rinse it with warm water. This can create a thin layer of water on the tray’s surface, which can help prevent sticking.

Use Distilled Water

Using distilled water can reduce the chances of ice cubes sticking since it has fewer impurities. This is especially helpful if you’re making clear ice cubes.

Use Cooking Spray or Vegetable Oil

Lightly coat the inside of the tray’s compartments with a small amount of cooking spray or vegetable oil. Be sure to wipe away any excess to prevent a noticeable taste in your ice cubes.

Tap or Twist the Tray 

To release the ice cubes, gently tap the bottom of the tray on the counter or twist the tray. Be careful not to overdo it; you don’t want to crack or damage the tray.


Choosing the best ice cube tray may appear to be a little consideration. Still, it can have a significant impact on your whole experience. Numerous factors must be considered, from the material and shape to ease of use and safety. By following this ultimate ice cube tray buying guide, you’ll be well-prepared to make an informed choice and ensure your drinks are always perfectly chilled. So, go ahead and pick the ice cube tray that suits your needs, and enjoy refreshing beverages with confidence. Cheers to keeping your cool!