Brown Sugar Pop Tart

Brown Sugar Pop Tart Where to Buy or How to Make at Home?

Pop tart is all about new flavors and a delicious treat that comes mainly with a frosting. But what if we say there are some flavors like brown sugar pop tart come unfrosted? Sounds a little unique?

Brown sugar pop tart is among the oldest flavor of pop tarts that initially came out in 1964. Since then, the taste has seen some variations, but it continues to be people’s favorite, and to date, it is one of the best-selling flavors of pop tarts that brings massive revenue for the company.

If you have ever tasted this flavor, you know how savory it is, and it comes with a hard-to-forget taste. We are also a fan of brown sugar cinnamon pop tart, so we researched in-depth details about the flavor to bring the best knowledge for you.

This article will help you learn about multiple types of brown sugar pop tart flavors, some fantastic recipes with nutritional content, and more facts you must know about your favorite flavor. We are sure you will attain some unique information that cannot be found elsewhere.

History of brown sugar pop tart

Before pop tarts, the market was ruled by another similar product called country squares. But in 1964, Kellogg’s, a famous confectionary brand, launched its first toaster pastry called pop tarts.

Initially, the four unfrosted flavors were found: Blueberry, Strawberry, Sugar-Cinnamon, and Apple Currant Jelly. To date, most of these flavors rule the market.

People loved the idea of pop-tarts, and the business took off. The company then launched a series of frosted pop tarts flavors and never looked back. Currently, they sell over 20 flavors, and on social media, you can find pop-tart fans have created images of hundreds of fake pop-tart flavors that never exist but show how viral the product is.

Brown sugar cinnamon is the longest-running flavor of pop tarts that people across the country still love. Even it’s among the rare flavors that still come unfrosted. If you are looking for a decent taste that is not too sugary and suitable to eat for breakfast, then you must try brown sugar pop tart.

Brown Sugar Pop Tart
Image Source: Flickr

Difference between Frosted and Unfrosted pop tart

These words are primarily used in the United States and are challenging to understand by people from other countries. But it’s simple! Frosted pop tarts include the cream between the wafers, while unfrosted pop tarts don’t have the cream. You can compare unfrosted pop tarts with ordinary biscuits, cookies, or wafers that don’t come with any filling inside.

Earlier, pop tarts only used to sell unfrosted flavors, but soon after the launch of frostings, the demand took off. These days mostly, you can find frosted flavors in supermarkets, while getting unfrosted flavors is difficult. Still, we have checked the unfrosted brown sugar pop tart is available on amazon.

Some reviews say that Kellogg’s has discontinued the unfrosted flavor, but it’s not true. It’s difficult to find because of low demand, but the taste is still available in the market.

Unique recipes to try with pop tart brown sugar?

Putting this flavor inside a microwave or toaster gives you a fantastic taste but imagine how delicious it could get if you add a few more ingredients. The combo of cinnamon, brown sugar and other components will give you an enhanced taste that you and your friends will love.

Let us quickly explore the recipes you can experiment with cinnamon pot tarts flavor.

Brown Sugar Pop Tart

1. Brown sugar cinnamon pop tart casserole

This recipe is best if you invite your friends for snacks. You can prepare it in bulk quantity, and it will efficiently serve 5-6 pop tart lovers. Make sure you follow the directions correctly to get the perfect taste.


  • 10 Slightly beaten eggs
  • Milk 2 cups
  • One tablespoon of Vanilla
  • Brown sugar approx. 1/3 cup
  • 8 cups of brioche bread, about 8 ounces in total.
  • 8 Kellogg’s brown sugar pastries, cut them into 1-inch pieces
  • Salt according to taste
  • Granulated sugar around 1/3 cup
  • one1 tablespoon ground cinnamon
  • Vanilla canned cup frosting of around 1/3 cup

The recipe

First, arrange all these ingredients in quantity mentioned, so you don’t have to run around for products while preparing the dish. Then follow these directions:

  1. Grease a baking dish and combine the brown sugar pop tart and bread. Please ensure you grease it properly so your plate doesn’t stick to the bottom while baking. You can mix the ingredients in another container, apply butter paper to the baking dish and flip the elements inside to bake.
  2. Mix vanilla, eggs, milk, brown sugar, and salt in a large bowl. Whisk it until it’s adequately blended, and then slowly pour the mixture inside your baking dish.
  3. Take a small bowl to mix granulated sugar and cinnamon to sprinkle over the casserole. Once you are done, cover the casserole and refrigerate it for 6 to 24 hours.
  4. Once completely frozen, take the casserole out of the refrigerator and let it rest at room temperature for 10 to 15 minutes. Then tightly cover it using foil and bake the covered casserole at 350 F for 20 minutes. Take it out and remove the covering to bake for another 10 to 20 minutes at 350 F.
  5. Insert a knife inside the casserole; if it comes out clean, it’s ready. But if the material sticks to your knife, you must bake it for another 10 to 15 minutes at the same temperature.
  6. Meanwhile, prepare the frosting and pour it inside the piping or food storage bag. Apply frosting to the casserole when you are ready to eat. We recommend you serve it warm.

It’s a simple yet effective method that even a beginner baker can do easily. The extra sugar and cinnamon enhance the flavor and provide much-needed taste with low effort.

2. Pop tart brown sugar pie

We understand that not everyone will like the idea of pop tart casserole. That’s why we brought another pie recipe for you. You can treat yourself to this delicious pie or make your friends taste it. We are pretty sure that you all will love the dish if you love eating pie. Let’s start with the ingredients.


  • 4 pieces of divided brown sugar pop tart
  • 2 packages of Jell-O, the cheesecake flavor with pie filling and pudding.
  • Get one portion of Kellogg’s readily available crust; you can get shortbread pie crust or Graham pie crust
  • ½ cup of apple pie filling and cold milk.
  • About 8 ounces of cool whip. Make sure to get a frozen, non-dairy whipped topping.

The recipe

This recipe is more straightforward and prepared quickly than the recipe mentioned above. If you have no experience making a pie, you can try it as a fun experiment and learn something new.

  1. First, take the readymade crust and apply ½ cup of pie filling. This will be the base of our tasty pie.
  2. Take a large bowl and pour milk and pudding mix to whisk it properly for a minute. Please ensure the mixture is thick enough so we can use it as a whipped topping.
  3. Crumble two of your favorite brown sugar pop tart, put them in the pudding mixture, and fold them until they are appropriately combined. (Save 1 cup of the mix to use as topping)
  4. Spread the freshly prepared filling on the pie crust and refrigerate it for at least three hours or until it’s correctly set.
  5. At last, spread the remaining pie filling, crumble two pop-tarts, and use them to garnish your pie. You decorate it as you like and store it in the refrigerator. Serve it cold and let your guest enjoy the fancy experiment you just did with pop-tart.

You can try these two recipes with your favorite cinnamon-flavored pop tart. Don’t worry if you have no experience preparing a pie or casserole. Browse some videos to get good knowledge, and you will be able to do it quickly.

Image Source: Flickr

How healthy is brown sugar pop tart?

Unfortunately, eating pop tarts doesn’t provide remarkable health benefits. Even some experts don’t recommend eating pop tarts because they contain a lot of sugar. Consuming them daily might adversely affect your health with weight gain, obesity, etc. However, you won’t face many issues if you occasionally consume it for taste. Frosted pop tart contains much more sugar compared to unfrosted ones.

If you are a fitness and health freak and still want to enjoy the delicious pop-tarts, we recommend you try the unfrosted flavor. You can also look for healthier alternatives to pop tarts on the Internet. It will help you a lot.

Calories in brown sugar pop tart

If you are on a strict diet, you must understand the calories you eat in each pop tart treat. It contains a lot of sugar, and we don’t recommend you eat too many pop tarts if you follow a gym routine or a diet. Still, this list of calorie breakdowns will help you.

Each serving (1 pastry) of pop tart contains 210 Calories which is further divided into:

  • Protein – 3.8%
  • Carbohydrates – 66.8%
  • Fats – 29.9

You will need an approx. 2.5 hours of exercise to burn this number of calories.

How much sugar does brown sugar pop tart has?

Each pop tart pastry contains total sugar of 30g with added sugar of 29 grams. It’s usually not recommended by experts to consume this much sugar in a single treat because consuming sugary products all day increases your overall sugar intake, negatively affecting your health. Occasionally it’s good, but it doesn’t make it a regular habit.

Where can I purchase pop tart brown sugar?

It’s the oldest flavor of pop tarts that has a steady demand throughout the year, and you can easily find the frosted cinnamon brown sugar pop tarts in your nearby supermarket or even in small retail stores if it’s not possible to visit and purchase pop tart, order online, and get the same-day delivery.

Frosted brown sugar pop tart is easy to find, but it is challenging to get the unfrosted ones because people don’t like them a lot. It’s hard to find them on supermarket shelves. Instead, we recommend you order online. The flavor is currently available in the unfrosted version on Amazon.

Are brown sugar pop tarts discontinued?

Pop-tarts are famous for launching new flavors and discontinuing them when the idea flops. However, the brown sugar flavor is the oldest flavor that people still love. Kellogg’s hasn’t stopped the taste yet and is still readily available in stores.

There are some rumors that the flavor has been discontinued, but it is fake news! The company is currently selling it.

Can I prepare these pop tarts at home?

Pop-tarts is a toaster pastries that anyone can prepare at home. Many videos on YouTube teach you the exact process with simple ingredients to prepare your favorite pop tarts at home. However, it’s challenging to get the taste provided by Kellogg’s.

If you are preparing it for the first time, don’t expect your pop-tarts to be perfect. The best part of preparing pop tarts at home is that you can try any flavor you want or even improvise the existing flavors currently being sold by the brand.

Want to amaze your friends with their favorite taste in pop tarts? Why not prepare it at home?

Final thoughts

That sums up the essential details of the brown sugar pop tart. It’s the longest-running flavor of pop tart that has secured a special place in people’s hearts. It isn’t easy to describe everything about the famous treat in a single article, but we hope you learn something new.

Please mention your unforgettable experiences with brown sugar pop tart in the comments? Also, if you are confused about the abovementioned recipes, please add them. We will try to help you at the earliest.

Try the unfrosted version of brown sugar pop tart; it’s delicious and comparatively healthier!