Candy Bar Madness FINALS!

In honor of March Madness, I’m running a ZOMG, Candy Madness contest! The original 16 have been whittled down to two: Reese’s Pieces versus Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. Leave a comment (with your email address which will be hidden and will only be used to contact you if you win) guessing which candy bar will come out on top, and go vote for your favorite!


Three names will be drawn from the pool of correct guesses to each win $20 worth of Baskin-Robbins Gift Certificates. Baskin-Robbins has teamed with up Hershey’s to create 13 different ice cream treats (sundaes, shakes, cakes, and more) made with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, Heath Bars, Kisses, and York Peppermint Patties. $20 could buy you a lot of candy bar ice cream! Leave a comment (with an email address) about which treat you’re most excited about trying for a second entry in the drawing.

Voting and contest entry will close at noon on Tuesday, March 25. Winners will be announced on Thursday, March 27. Good luck!

  • oh Reeses Peanut Butter Cups for sure! 🙂

  • Jessica

    I KNOW that Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups will come out on top. Everyone loves the Peanut Butter Cups! I would always go for that over the Pieces. I am suprised that Reese’s Pieces is in the top two!

  • Jessica

    I am so excited about trying the Baskin Robbins Reece’s Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream! The only problem – it is just a flavor of the month, which means it won’t last forever! They should make it a permanent flavor! I can taste it now – a waffle bowl sundae with peanut butter sauce, marshmellows, and peanuts. My mouth is watering!

  • I knew it! Cups all the way. There is no better candy out there, and the only way this poll could be honed further would be to ask what size/shape of cups people prefer? It will be miniatures, followed by Reese’s Eggs and then regular ol’ cups.

  • Ryan

    Well, i’ll have to agree and say that Reeses Peanut Butter Cups are more exciting and delectable. I actually prefer the seasonal varieties (eggs, trees, etc.) more than the cups, but they are practically one in the same. Mmmmm!

  • Jessica

    @Ryan –
    I also prefer the seasonal varieties! There is more peanut butter in them…

  • Mike L.

    Cups all the way. Cannot defeat the OG.

  • Skye

    I’m sure the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups will win. The Pieces are too sweet, smooth, and oily.

    I’m most excited about the York sundae creations at Baskin-Robbins, but I expect to try a few of the others! I LOVED the stuff they did with Oreo last year.




    while reeses cups are amazing, you can only eat a few before feeling bloated and unhealthy. However you can eat an entire box of reeses pieces and still feel good

  • amy

    Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups will triumph. There’s just something perfect about that peanut butter and chocolate combo. The best!

  • Gregg

    Reece’s Pieces will come out on top. I think that the pieces taste better than any candy out there!

  • Gregg

    I am looking forward the the Reece’s Peanut Butter Ice Cream the most. It sounds like heaven!

  • I can’t even imagine really anything better than a Reese’s peanutbutter cup treat such as this–what a dream to come true

  • HUrray for Reese’s-they are and always will be the winner in my book.

  • Tabatha

    I’m guessing that reese’s peanut butter cups will win the poll.

  • Tabatha

    I’m excited to try their peanut butter cup flavor!

  • Thanks for providing information and prices of different variety of shopping product. I need this info because i am using online shopping services.